Oatmeal Raisin

Split one with my afternoon coffee and the center was still so moist it barely needed chewing, while the edges had that perfect golden crunch. The raisins are genuinely plump, not those shriveled sad ones you get in most store-bought cookies. I ordered the box of eight and they're dangerously easy t

The six-ounce weight is no joke—I cut one into four pieces and still felt like I'd had dessert. The outside is properly golden while the inside stays soft, and those raisins are genuinely plump, not dried-out little nubs.

Finally, a cookie that actually earns its six ounces — the inside stays so soft and moist while the raisins are genuinely plump, not those shriveled things you get elsewhere. I ordered the eight-pack for a family gathering and they were gone before dinner.