The $45 question: what are you actually buying?
The From NYC, With Love Gift Set is a bundle, not just a box of cookies. Alongside your choice of four cookies, it includes a Literie "Afternoon in Central Park" candle and an exclusive Levain x Crate & Barrel embroidered kitchen towel featuring original artwork by illustrator Libby VanderPloeg. The catalog lists it at $45.00, compared with a $90.00 comparison price.
That combination is the whole value proposition. If you only want cookies, a straight cookie box will always be the more efficient buy. The set earns its price when the candle and towel do real work: as a host gift, a welcome-to-New-York present, or a send-off for someone leaving the city.
What the bundle includes
- From NYC, With Love Gift Set: Your choice of 4 ooey, gooey cookies, plus a Literie "Afternoon in Central Park" candle and an exclusive Levain x Crate & Barrel embroidered kitchen towel. The cookie count is modest, so the candle and towel are not extras—they are half the gift. Judge the price against all three components.

From NYC, With Love Gift Set - From NYC, With Love Gift Set: The candle smells of summer days in Sheep Meadow, with notes of grass and bergamot. This is a specific, place-based scent rather than a generic candle. It suits someone with a real attachment to Central Park; it may mean less to a recipient with no New York reference point.
- From NYC, With Love Gift Set: The set is positioned for welcoming someone to New York, celebrating a good run here, or sending a reminder of the city to an ex-New Yorker. The brand frames the gift around New York identity. That framing is the best guide to whether it fits your recipient.
When it's worth it for New Yorkers
For a local, the set makes the most sense as a gift you give someone else—not a treat you buy for your own kitchen. It works for a friend who just moved into a first apartment, a colleague who is leaving the city, or a host who has done you several favors and deserves something more considered than a bottle of wine.
The towel is the quiet standout for locals. It is a usable kitchen item with original artwork, and it does not look like a souvenir-shop purchase. The candle is the more personal piece: the Sheep Meadow reference will land with someone who actually spends time in the park, and read as decorative filler to someone who does not.
When it's worth it for travelers and gift senders
If you are visiting and want a New York-themed cookie gift to bring home, the set solves a common problem: it gives you something to hand over that is not another I Love NY mug. The candle and towel pack flat and travel better than a cookie tin, though the candle is glass and needs padding in a suitcase.
For anyone sending a reminder of the city to an ex-New Yorker, the set does the storytelling for you. The candle supplies the Central Park reference and the towel supplies the daily-use reminder. The four cookies are the part that gets eaten first.
Which cookie style should you choose?
The Style option changes the cookie assortment, so pick it with your recipient in mind rather than defaulting to the first choice.
- Signature Assortment: The safe default when you do not know the recipient's preferences or dietary needs.
- Chocolate Lovers or Decadent Assortment: Better for someone who treats dessert as a chocolate-first decision rather than a variety exercise.
- Chocolate Chip Walnut, Two Chip Chocolate Chip, or Nuts About Summer Assortment: Choose these when you know the recipient likes a specific Levain classic or wants a nut-forward mix.
- Vegan & GF Chocolate Chip Walnut: The set's only listed option that signals a vegan and gluten-free cookie choice. Confirm the recipient's needs directly; the supplied information does not describe allergen handling or cross-contact practices.
The trade-offs worth knowing before you order
Four cookies is a small count for a household, so this is a gift set rather than a party supply. If you need cookies for a crowd, the bundle is the wrong shape and a larger cookie box or sleeve makes more sense.
The supplied product information does not list ingredients, allergens, shelf life, or storage instructions for the cookies, and it does not give candle burn time or care instructions. Treat those as questions to confirm with the store before you rely on the set for a recipient with dietary restrictions or for a gift that needs to sit for weeks before it is opened.
The candle's scent is the biggest wildcard. Grass and bergamot is a fresh, green profile, not a sweet bakery scent. If you are buying for someone who prefers warm or food-forward fragrances, the towel and cookies may carry more of the gift's weight than the candle does.
A quick way to decide
- Name the occasion: Welcome, farewell, thank-you, or holiday host gift. If you cannot name one, a plain cookie box is the simpler purchase.
- Check the New York connection: The set's value depends on the recipient having a real relationship with the city. Without that, the candle and towel lose their meaning.
- Pick the cookie style deliberately: Match the assortment to what you know about the recipient, and choose the Vegan & GF Chocolate Chip Walnut option only after confirming their dietary needs.
- Confirm the details the listing does not cover: Ask about ingredients, allergens, and storage before ordering for anyone with restrictions or for a gift that will not be opened promptly.


